Home / Best Payroll Software Comparison

Best Payroll Software Comparison: 8 Providers Compared

Read the best payroll software comparison for small and midsize teams, with pricing, tax filing, HR features, multi state pay, and provider trade offs.

Best Payroll Software Comparison
  1. Editor's choice
    Gusto logoGusto

    Clear payroll pricing

    Starts at$49 per month plus $6 per person
    Visit gusto.comFull review
  2. Great alternative
    OnPay logoOnPay

    Simple all in payroll

    Starts at$49 per month plus $6 per person
    Visit onpay.comFull review
  3. Also consider
    ADP RUN logoADP RUN

    Scale and compliance depth

    Starts atSee website
    Visit adp.comFull review

TL;DR:

  • Gusto and OnPay offer the clearest published payroll pricing, with base fees plus a per person rate that makes budgeting simple.
  • ADP and Paychex suit larger or compliance heavy employers, but their pricing is quote based, so you must compare written quotes, not list prices.
  • Rippling is the best fit when payroll must sit inside a wider HR, IT, and finance system, though its modular pricing needs careful review.
  • Square Payroll fits hourly and retail teams that already use Square, while Patriot is the lowest cost path for simple full service payroll.
  • The cheapest base fee is rarely the cheapest total. Add ons for multi state payroll, time tracking, benefits, and support change the real monthly cost.

Quick comparison

ToolBest forStarts atFree plan?
GustoClear payroll pricing$49 per month plus $6 per personNoVisit
OnPaySimple all in payroll$49 per month plus $6 per personFree trialVisit
ADP RUNScale and compliance depthSee websiteNoVisit
Paychex FlexMidsize payroll and HRSee websiteNoVisit
RipplingPayroll inside a wider platformFrom $8 per user per monthNoVisit
Square PayrollHourly and retail teams$35 per month plus $6 per personNoVisit
Patriot PayrollLow cost full service payroll$37 per month plus $4 per personFree trialVisit
PaycorMidsize payroll with HR toolsSee websiteNoVisit

The best payroll software comparison

We compared providers on published pricing, tax filing, multi state coverage, contractor payments, time tracking, benefits, and support. We used vendor pricing pages and recent comparison guides, and we note where pricing is quote based rather than publishing a number we could not verify.

Gusto logo
#1

Gusto

Best for: Clear payroll pricing

Visit gusto.com
Starts at$49 per month plus $6 per person
Free plan?No
Gusto app screenshots
App Store screenshots

Gusto is the easiest payroll provider to compare, because its pricing is published and its tiers are clear. Simple costs $49 a month plus $6 per person, Plus costs $80 plus $12, and Premium costs $180 plus $22, with unlimited payroll runs and automatic federal, state, and local tax filings on every plan. There is no long term contract, setup is free, and you can switch plans as headcount changes.

The limits are tier placement. Simple covers payroll in one state only, so multi state teams need Plus, and time tracking also sits on Plus. Premium adds a named advisor and compliance tools, but it requires a sales conversation before you can switch on. Gusto also pays employees in the United States only, with contractor payments abroad as a separate add on. For a small or midsize United States team that wants transparent payroll pricing, Gusto sets the standard other providers are judged against.

Pros
  • Published tiers with no contract
  • Unlimited payroll runs
  • Automatic tax filings
Cons
  • Multi state payroll needs Plus
  • Time tracking needs Plus
  • International payroll limited to contractors
OnPay logo
#2

OnPay

Best for: Simple all in payroll

Visit onpay.com
Starts at$49 per month plus $6 per person
Free plan?Free trial
OnPay app screenshots
App Store screenshots

OnPay keeps payroll deliberately simple. One plan, currently $49 a month plus $6 per worker, includes unlimited payroll runs, multi state payroll, full service tax filing, year end W-2 and 1099 forms, and basic HR tools such as onboarding, PTO, and document storage. There are no feature tiers to decode, and OnPay backs its tax filing with a guarantee that it will fix its mistakes and pay resulting fines or interest.

That simplicity has a ceiling. OnPay lacks the deep HR, performance, and IT features of Rippling, and premium benefits such as workers compensation and 401(k) administration are billed separately. Teams that want payroll plus a full HRIS may outgrow OnPay, though many small businesses never do. If you want full service payroll at a clear price with multi state coverage included, OnPay is hard to beat.

Pros
  • One plan with all features included
  • Multi state payroll at no extra cost
  • Error free tax filing guarantee
Cons
  • Fewer HR depth features than larger platforms
  • Benefits add ons cost extra
  • Interface is simpler than rivals
ADP RUN logo
#3

ADP RUN

Best for: Scale and compliance depth

Visit adp.com
Starts atSee website
Free plan?No
ADP RUN website
adp.com homepage

ADP RUN is the payroll platform for businesses that expect to grow and want a vendor that can grow with them. It offers payroll, tax filing, time and attendance, benefits, and HR tools, with compliance depth built from decades of serving employers of every size. Reporting is strong, and businesses that later need enterprise ADP products can move within the same vendor family.

Pricing is quote based, and published estimates vary widely by headcount and package, so you cannot compare ADP to Gusto on list prices alone. Setup can also take longer, and support experience varies by the package you buy. If compliance, scale, and a long term vendor relationship matter more than a low starting price, ADP RUN deserves a quote. Get the quote in writing with every module itemized, and compare it at your exact headcount.

Pros
  • Deep compliance and tax expertise
  • Scales from small to large employers
  • Strong reporting
Cons
  • Quote based pricing
  • Setup can be slow
  • Support quality varies by package
Paychex Flex logo
#4

Paychex Flex

Best for: Midsize payroll and HR

Visit paychex.com
Starts atSee website
Free plan?No

Paychex Flex serves small to midsize employers with payroll, tax administration, time and attendance, benefits, and HR tools in one platform. Its service model is a strength, with dedicated support options that appeal to employers who want a person to call when payroll questions arise. Paychex also handles complex pay situations, including multiple locations, hourly workers, and varied pay schedules.

Like ADP, Paychex prices by quote, and published comparisons put starting points near $65 a month plus $8 per employee, though your quote will differ. Add ons for time, benefits, and HR services raise the total, and the breadth of the platform can feel complex for a very small team. For a midsize employer that values service and payroll depth, Paychex Flex is a strong contender. Ask for a quote that separates payroll, time, and HR costs so you can compare fairly.

Pros
  • Strong payroll and tax service
  • Dedicated support options
  • Broad HR and benefits tools
Cons
  • Quote based pricing
  • Costs rise with add ons
  • Interface can feel complex
Rippling logo
#5

Rippling

Best for: Payroll inside a wider platform

Visit rippling.com
Starts atFrom $8 per user per month
Free plan?No

Rippling treats payroll as one module in a wider system that also manages HR, devices, apps, and spend. When an employee record changes, payroll, benefits, IT access, and finance update together, which removes the duplicate entry that causes many payroll errors. Global payroll and employer of record services extend that model to international teams, and automation handles onboarding, offboarding, and approvals in one workflow.

Pricing is modular and quote based. The platform starts from $8 per user per month, with payroll and other products bought separately, so the total depends on your module mix. Setup also takes longer than a payroll only tool. Rippling fits companies that want payroll inside a unified people platform and are willing to pay for that integration. If you only need payroll, a payroll only provider is simpler and usually cheaper.

Pros
  • Payroll flows from one employee record across HR, IT, and finance
  • Global payroll options
  • Deep automation
Cons
  • Modular quote based pricing
  • Payroll is an add on to the platform
  • Setup takes longer
Square Payroll logo
#6

Square Payroll

Best for: Hourly and retail teams

Visit square.com
Starts at$35 per month plus $6 per person
Free plan?No

Square Payroll suits businesses that already run on Square, such as cafes, retailers, and service shops with hourly staff. Time worked in Square point of sale or time tools flows into payroll, which cuts manual entry for shift based teams. Pricing starts at $35 a month plus $6 per person for W-2 payroll, with a contractor only option for businesses that pay 1099 workers only.

Outside the Square ecosystem, Square Payroll is thinner than Gusto or OnPay on HR depth, benefits administration, and multi state complexity. It is a payroll tool first, not a full HRIS, and teams with salaried staff across many states may need more. If your team already uses Square for sales and scheduling, Square Payroll is the natural, low friction choice. If you do not use Square, compare it against Gusto and OnPay on total cost and features.

Pros
  • Works well with Square point of sale
  • Simple for hourly teams
  • Contractor only plan available
Cons
  • Fewer HR features than full HRIS tools
  • Multi state and benefits depth limited
  • Best inside the Square ecosystem
Patriot Payroll logo
#7

Patriot Payroll

Best for: Low cost full service payroll

Visit patriot.com
Starts at$37 per month plus $4 per person
Free plan?Free trial

Patriot Payroll is the budget pick that still files taxes for you. Full service payroll costs $37 a month plus $4 per person, with tax calculation, filing, and year end forms included, while a cheaper basic plan lets businesses file taxes themselves. The interface is simple, setup is quick, and a free trial lets small teams test payroll before paying.

The trade offs are breadth and polish. Patriot has fewer integrations than Gusto or Rippling, its HR tools are basic, and support is more limited than larger vendors. It suits small businesses with straightforward payroll, few locations, and simple pay rules. If your payroll involves many states, complex benefits, or deep HR needs, a larger provider will serve you better, but you will pay more for it.

Pros
  • Lowest cost full service option on this list
  • Simple interface
  • Free trial available
Cons
  • Fewer integrations than larger rivals
  • HR features are basic
  • Support hours are limited compared with larger vendors
Paycor logo
#8

Paycor

Best for: Midsize payroll with HR tools

Visit paycor.com
Starts atSee website
Free plan?No

Paycor rounds out this comparison as a midsize payroll and HR platform, with payroll, tax filing, time and attendance, recruiting, onboarding, benefits, and performance tools. Its compliance depth suits employers with hourly workers, multiple locations, or complex pay rules, and its reporting helps HR leaders track labor cost, turnover, and headcount without manual spreadsheets.

Pricing is quote based, and Paycor is built for midsize teams, so very small businesses may find it more than they need and more costly than Gusto or Patriot. Implementation also needs planning around pay rules and time policies. For a midsize employer comparing ADP and Paychex, Paycor belongs in the same conversation, especially if recruiting and onboarding matter alongside payroll. Get a written quote and compare it at your headcount, not on headline rates.

Pros
  • Payroll plus recruiting, time, and HR in one platform
  • Strong compliance for midsize employers
  • Good reporting
Cons
  • Quote based pricing
  • Implementation needs planning
  • Less suited to very small teams

How we picked these

We compared providers that serve small and midsize employers in the United States, using vendor pricing pages and recent comparison guides. We favored providers with full service tax filing, multi state coverage, and clear pricing or a clear quote process, and we flagged quote based pricing rather than inventing numbers. We weighed payroll accuracy, ease of running a pay cycle, contractor support, and integration with accounting tools alongside price, since payroll mistakes cost far more than a monthly fee difference.

Comparing payroll providers fairly

Compare totals at your headcount

Build a simple table for your team size. List the base fee, per person fee, and every add on you need, including multi state payroll, time tracking, benefits administration, and support upgrades. Run that table for 10, 25, and 50 employees if you plan to grow, since per person pricing changes the ranking as headcount rises.

Run a test payroll before you switch

Ask each finalist for a trial or demo payroll using your real pay types, including hourly, salaried, overtime, and contractor payments. Check how tax filings, direct deposit timing, and year end forms are handled, and confirm cutoff times for payroll submission. A smooth test payroll predicts a smooth first live payroll.

Check support when payroll goes wrong

Payroll problems are time sensitive, so confirm support hours, phone availability, and response times before you buy. Ask who fixes a tax filing error and who pays any resulting penalty, since guarantees differ. OnPay publishes a tax filing guarantee, while other vendors handle errors under their service terms, so read those terms for your finalists.

FAQ

What is the best payroll software?

Gusto and OnPay are the best general picks for small businesses because of clear pricing and full service tax filing. ADP and Paychex suit larger or compliance heavy employers, Rippling suits companies that want payroll inside a wider platform, and Square Payroll suits hourly teams already using Square.

How does a top payroll software comparison work?

A fair comparison lists the base fee, per person fee, and add ons for the same headcount, then checks tax filing, multi state coverage, time tracking, benefits, and support. Comparing base fees alone misleads, since add ons and tier placement change the total more than the starting price.

How much does payroll software cost?

Published starting points range from $35 to $49 a month plus $4 to $6 per person for payroll focused tools, while larger providers quote by headcount and package. For a 10 person team, expect roughly $75 to $200 a month for full service payroll before benefits and time add ons, depending on the provider and plan.

Does payroll software file taxes for me?

Full service payroll providers calculate, file, and pay federal, state, and local payroll taxes and produce year end W-2 and 1099 forms. Basic or self service plans may calculate taxes but leave filing to you, so confirm whether filing is included before you choose a low cost plan.

Can payroll software pay contractors?

Yes, most providers on this list pay 1099 contractors alongside W-2 employees and generate 1099 forms at year end. Some offer contractor only plans for businesses with no W-2 staff, and contractor fees are usually charged only in months you pay them, so confirm the billing rule for your provider.

When should a business switch payroll providers?

Common triggers are growth into new states, a move to hourly or shift based staff, benefits complexity, or repeated payroll errors. Switch at a quarter boundary when possible, keep old payroll records accessible, and run a parallel or test payroll before the first live run with the new provider.

Sources

✓
Shihab Mia

I'm Shihab Mia, and I run LinkVetted. I vet every link placement against live Ahrefs data, and everything I publish follows the same standard I sell: verifiable claims and no inflated metrics.