Best Payroll Services for Hiring a Nanny in 2026: 8 Services Compared
Find the best payroll services for hiring a nanny, with pay runs, tax filings, W-2s and direct deposit compared for one household employee in 2026 today.

- Editor's choice
Poppins PayrollMost families
Starts at$49 per monthVisit poppinspayroll.comFull review - Great alternative
SurePayrollLow-cost pay runs
Starts at$45 per monthVisit surepayroll.comFull review - Also consider
HomePay by Care.comCare.com families
Starts at$59 per monthVisit homepay.comFull review
TL;DR:
- Poppins Payroll at 49 dollars per month is our pick for most families because one flat plan covers pay runs, filings and year-end forms.
- SurePayroll at 45 dollars per month is the lowest cost full-service option here, but check whether year-end forms cost extra on your plan.
- HomePay and GTM cost more, yet they suit families who want a long track record, a dedicated team or help with benefits and insurance.
- A do-it-yourself option such as NannyKeeper can cut the yearly bill a lot, but you file the forms yourself.
- Always confirm state coverage, overtime rules and whether your state requires workers compensation before your first pay run.
Quick comparison
| Tool | Best for | Starts at | Free plan? | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Most families | $49 per month | Free trial | Visit | |
| Low-cost pay runs | $45 per month | Free trial | Visit | |
| Care.com families | $59 per month | No | Visit | |
| Expert support and benefits | $70 per month | No | Visit | |
| Concierge support | $65 per month | No | Visit | |
| Back taxes and catch-up | $42 per month | No | Visit | |
| Budget households | $39 per month | No | Visit | |
| Do-it-yourself filing | See website | Free plan | Visit |
The best payroll services for hiring a nanny
Hiring a nanny makes you a household employer in most cases, which means payroll taxes, wage rules and year-end forms apply. We compared services on price, filings included, support and how well they handle state rules, using vendor pages and recent comparison guides.

Poppins Payroll is our pick for most families because the price is simple and complete. One plan at 49 dollars per month covers pay runs, tax calculations, filings and year-end forms, including W-2 and Schedule H, for active customers. That clarity matters when other services add fees later for forms you assumed were included. Support comes from household payroll specialists, and the service operates in all 50 states.
The main drawback is that there is no cheaper light plan if you pay a nanny only a few hours a month. Even so, the all-in price compares well with higher tier plans elsewhere once year-end fees are added. If you want one predictable bill and no add-on surprises, start here.
- One flat plan
- Year-end forms included
- Specialists for all 50 states
- No tiered plan for very light use
- Extra employees cost 10 dollars per month each

SurePayroll, by Paychex, offers household payroll from 45 dollars per month for one employee, with 10 dollars per month for each extra employee. That makes it the cheapest full-service starting price in this guide. Pay runs, direct deposit and tax calculations are straightforward, and the Paychex backing gives families confidence that the system will stay online and supported.
Check the fine print before you sign up, because W-2 preparation has been listed as a separate add-on on the household plan in comparison guides. If that fee applies to you, the yearly total moves closer to Poppins. Still, for families who want a low monthly cost and a well-known payroll brand, SurePayroll is a strong choice.
- Low monthly price
- Direct deposit
- Part of Paychex
- Year-end forms may be a paid add-on
- Interface is more general business focused

HomePay, from Care.com, is one of the longest running household payroll services, with roots in Breedlove and Associates. The Essentials plan starts at 59 dollars per month and the Plus plan at 75 dollars per month, with a free Care.com membership on Plus. Filings are handled for you, which suits families who do not want to touch a tax form.
The price is the sticking point. At 708 dollars a year for Essentials before the year-end form fee, it costs more than Poppins and SurePayroll for similar core work. Choose HomePay if you already use Care.com, value its long history, or want the Plus plan dedicated team. Otherwise, a cheaper service will do the same filings.
- Long track record through Breedlove
- Filings handled for you
- Plus plan adds a dedicated team
- Higher price
- Year-end forms cost 100 dollars extra on both plans in comparisons
GTM Payroll Services focuses only on household employment, and that focus shows in its advice. Its plans start around 70 dollars per month in comparison guides, with extra employees at 20 dollars per month. Beyond payroll, GTM can help with workers compensation, health insurance and retirement options, which matters when a nanny becomes a long-term employee with benefits.
Families who only need basic pay runs may find GTM more than they need, and setup plus year-end fees can add to the first year cost. If your situation is complex, such as a nanny share, multiple employees or a state with strict domestic worker rules, the expert guidance can be worth the premium.
- Household employment experts
- Help with workers compensation and benefits
- Nanny tax calculator
- Higher entry price
- Setup and year-end fees may apply
HomeWork Solutions has served household employers for more than 30 years and offers a concierge style service with free consultations in all 50 states. Comparison guides list its pricing around 195 dollars per quarter for one employee, which works out to about 65 dollars per month. That includes payroll processing and tax filing support, with options for weekly or biweekly pay.
The service suits families who want a person to talk to and a clear onboarding process, rather than a purely self-serve website. It is not the cheapest option, and families comfortable with online tools may prefer Poppins or SurePayroll. If personal support matters more than saving 15 dollars a month, HomeWork Solutions earns its place here.
- More than 30 years in household payroll
- Free consultations
- Multiple payment options
- Price is above budget options
- Quarterly billing may feel less flexible
Nest Payroll starts at 42 dollars per month for one employee in comparison guides, placing it among the cheaper full-service options. It is often noted for helping families who need to sort out back taxes and get compliant after paying a nanny without formal payroll. That help can save a stressful conversation with a tax adviser later.
As a smaller provider, Nest does not have the same brand recognition as the larger services, so read recent reviews and confirm exactly which filings are included. For a family that needs catch-up help at a moderate price, it is a practical pick. For a brand new, simple hire, Poppins still offers a clearer all-in package.
- Lower monthly price
- Help with back taxes
- Household focus
- Smaller brand than Poppins or HomePay
- Check state coverage for your situation
Savvy Nanny Payroll is listed in comparison guides at 39 dollars per month for two employees, which makes it one of the best values for families with more than one household worker. It covers the core needs: pay calculations, tax withholding and filing support, without the extra layers that push prices higher elsewhere.
The trade-off is a leaner service. Families who want benefits help, insurance guidance or a dedicated account team should look at GTM or HomePay instead. If your goal is compliant, low-cost payroll for a nanny and perhaps a second helper, Savvy is worth a close look, provided you confirm year-end forms are included in your plan.
- Low price for two employees in guides
- Simple household payroll
- Tax support
- Fewer premium support options
- Confirm year-end forms included
NannyKeeper takes a different approach. It calculates payroll taxes, generates W-2, Schedule H and pay stubs, and sends deadline reminders, while you submit the forms yourself in about 15 minutes a quarter, according to its own guides. Its Plus plan is listed around 180 dollars a year, far below full-service prices, and basic payment tracking is free.
That saving only works if you are comfortable filing forms and paying tax agencies directly. Families who want someone else to press submit should choose Poppins or SurePayroll instead. For confident, budget focused households, NannyKeeper keeps the maths right at a fraction of the usual cost.
- Very low cost
- Payment tracking free
- Calculates taxes and generates forms
- You file the forms yourself
- Less hand-holding than full-service options
How we picked these
We compared vendor pricing pages and recent independent comparison guides, checking starting price, filings included, year-end forms, extra employee fees and state coverage. We favoured services that clearly serve household employers, publish household pricing and handle federal and state filings or give clear tools to do so. Prices change, so confirm the current plan details before you enroll.
How to choose the right nanny payroll service
Start with what you will actually do
If you want no paperwork at all, pick a full-service option that files quarterly and year-end forms for you. If you are happy to file a short form each quarter, a do-it-yourself tool can save hundreds of dollars a year. Be honest about how much admin time you will really give this each month.
Check your state rules first
Some states have domestic worker laws, paid sick leave rules or workers compensation requirements that go beyond federal rules. Ask the provider how it handles your state, overtime and any local taxes. A service that is strong nationally but weak in your state is not a good fit.
Count the full year cost
Add the monthly fee, setup fee, extra employee fees and any year-end form fee. A 45 dollar plan with a separate W-2 fee can cost more over a year than a 49 dollar all-in plan. Get the total in writing before your first pay run, and set up direct deposit and a pay schedule your nanny can rely on.
FAQ
Do I need payroll if I only pay a nanny part time?
In many cases yes, once wages pass federal thresholds for Social Security, Medicare and unemployment taxes, and state rules may apply sooner. A household payroll service can check the thresholds for your state and pay frequency.
What forms does a nanny payroll service handle?
Most full-service options handle quarterly tax filings, year-end W-2 and W-3 forms and Schedule H for your personal tax return. Confirm whether those year-end forms are included or billed separately before you choose.
Can one service handle a nanny share?
A nanny share usually means each family is a separate employer, so each family needs its own payroll account and its own W-2 for the nanny. Ask the provider how it sets up shared care and whether it offers any discount for linked families.
What happens if I have paid a nanny without payroll before?
You can usually get compliant by setting up payroll now and filing catch-up returns for past periods. Services such as Nest Payroll and GTM note help with back taxes, and a tax adviser can help if several years are involved.
Is workers compensation required for a nanny?
It depends on your state. Some states require it for household employees, while others make it voluntary but strongly recommended. Ask your provider or insurer about your state rule before your nanny starts work.




