Best Cheap Payroll Software in 2026: 8 Tools Compared
We compared the best cheap payroll software for 2026 on base fees, per person costs and tax filing, to help small firms find a low cost payroll service.

- Editor's choice
Patriot PayrollLowest full service cost
Starts at$37 per monthVisit patriotsoftware.comFull review - Great alternative
Square PayrollRetail and restaurant teams
Starts at$35 per monthVisit squareup.comFull review - Also consider
GustoMost small teams
Starts at$49 per monthVisit gusto.comFull review
TL;DR:
- Cheap payroll is only a bargain if tax filing is included, so compare full service prices, not just headline monthly fees.
- Patriot Full Service and Square Payroll are among the lowest published full service options, near $37 plus $5 and $35 plus $6 per person.
- Gusto and OnPay cost a little more but add HR, onboarding and benefits that many small teams value.
- A basic plan that leaves tax filing to you can look cheap and cost hours each quarter, so read the plan details carefully.
- This is general information only, not tax or financial advice, and payroll rules vary by state and situation.
Quick comparison
| Tool | Best for | Starts at | Free plan? | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lowest full service cost | $37 per month | No | Visit | |
| Retail and restaurant teams | $35 per month | No | Visit | |
| Most small teams | $49 per month | No | Visit | |
| Flat price with all features | $49 per month | No | Visit | |
| Long free trial | $29.99 per month | No | Visit | |
| Wave accounting users | $35 per month | No | Visit | |
| Hourly worker teams | $39 per month | No | Visit | |
| QuickBooks Online users | $50 per month | No | Visit |
The best cheap payroll software
Cheap payroll software, also called a cheap payroll service, should run pay, file taxes and issue year end forms without surprise fees. These eight tools cover that work at low published prices.
Patriot is the price leader for full service payroll in recent comparisons. Full Service starts near $37 per month plus $5 per worker, and it files federal, state and local taxes for you. Basic starts near $17 per month plus $4 per worker, but it does not file taxes, so most owners should compare Full Service, not Basic, when judging value.
The catch is scope. Multi state payroll adds per state charges, and HR and benefits features are thinner than at Gusto or OnPay. Support is US based and well rated, which helps when a tax question arises. For a single state, budget first owner who wants full filing at the lowest published price, Patriot is the pick to beat.
- Lowest published full service price
- US based support
- Clear tiers
- Basic tier does not file taxes for you
- Multi state adds per state charges

Square Payroll starts near $35 per month plus $6 per employee, which is the lowest base fee for employee payroll among several leading picks. Hours import straight from Square timecards, which saves retail and restaurant managers from retyping shifts. A contractor only option charges $6 per contractor with no base fee, which is the cheapest route for 1099 only teams.
The value is strongest inside Square. Firms not using Square POS lose the hours advantage, though payroll and tax filing still work well. HR features are thinner than at Gusto, so teams that need deep onboarding or benefits may prefer a broader tool. For a shop already on Square, it is a natural, low cost choice.
- Lowest base fee for employee payroll in many lists
- Hours import from Square POS
- Contractor only option
- Best value inside Square ecosystem
- HR features thinner than Gusto

Gusto Simple starts near $49 per month plus $6 per person, which costs more than Patriot or Square, but it adds value many teams use every week. It files taxes in all 50 states, handles onboarding, time off and benefits, and guides owners through state registrations in plain language. The interface explains what payroll is doing, rather than assuming payroll knowledge.
The entry plan covers one state, so multi location firms move to a higher tier, and the per person rate rises on Plus. For a growing small team that wants payroll plus HR basics in one login, the extra $10 to $14 per month over the cheapest options often pays for itself in saved time and fewer errors.
- Full service tax filing in all states
- Onboarding and benefits
- Clear interface
- Higher base fee than Patriot or Square
- Entry plan covers one state
OnPay offers one plan with every feature included, near $49 per month plus $6 per person in recent lists, with some older lists showing $40 plus $6. That flat model removes tier guessing. Payroll, tax filing, benefits administration, time off and HR basics sit in one price, and multi state payroll is handled without the tier jump found at some rivals.
Benefits options are narrower than at Gusto, and the interface is plainer, but the simplicity appeals to owners who dislike upsells. For a multi state small team that wants every feature without checking which tier includes it, OnPay is a strong value pick. Confirm the current base fee on the vendor page before you sign, since it has moved.
- Every feature at one price
- No tier upgrades
- Multi state simplicity
- Price has varied between $40 and $49 base in recent lists
- Fewer benefits options than Gusto
SurePayroll has been listed from $29.99 per month plus $5 per person, with a six month free trial in some offers, which is the longest trial among the tools here. It files taxes, handles direct deposit, and offers a household employer plan for nanny and caregiver payroll, which is a niche many rivals handle less well. Multi state payroll adds a flat fee near $9.99, which keeps costs predictable.
Trial terms and pricing can vary by offer, so read the current terms on the vendor page. Support and interface feedback is mixed compared with Gusto, but the low entry price and long trial make it easy to test. For a budget first owner, especially a household employer, SurePayroll is worth a trial.
- Low starting price
- Six month free trial in some offers
- Household employer plan
- Trial terms vary
- Multi state adds a flat fee
Wave Payroll starts near $35 per month plus $6 per person in tax service states, and it pairs with Wave free accounting, which many microbusinesses already use. That pairing keeps books and payroll in one place without a monthly accounting fee, which is a real saving for a solo owner or tiny team.
The limit is tax service coverage, listed at 14 states in recent guides, with other states getting calculation but not full filing service. That makes Wave a poor fit for firms outside those states that need full filing. For a Wave user inside a tax service state, it is a cheap, simple payroll add on.
- Ties to free Wave accounting
- Simple payroll for small teams
- Low base fee
- Tax service limited to 14 states
- No dedicated mobile app
Homebase starts as scheduling and time tracking, then adds payroll, which suits hourly teams in retail, food service and care. Staff can clock in, swap shifts and view schedules, and hours flow into payroll without retyping. Payroll pricing has been listed near $39 per month plus $6 per person, with hiring and team communication tools in the wider platform.
Firms that only need payroll, without scheduling, may find the wider platform more than they need, and the per person cost sits above Patriot. For an hourly team that already needs scheduling, though, the combined flow is the value, since it removes the hours to payroll handoff that causes most errors.
- Scheduling and time tracking built in
- Good for hourly teams
- Hiring tools
- Payroll is part of a wider platform
- Higher per person cost than Patriot
QuickBooks Payroll, sold as QuickBooks Workforce payroll, starts near $50 per month plus $7 per worker in recent lists, with some lists showing $6.50 per worker, plus the cost of QuickBooks Online itself. That total is higher than Patriot or Square alone, but the value is the link. Payroll journal entries post to the books without export, and accounting, payroll and payments share one login.
Firms not already on QuickBooks should compare the bundle total against a standalone payroll tool plus their current accounting cost. For a firm already committed to QuickBooks Online, the joined up books and tax filing make it a sensible, if not the cheapest, choice.
- Payroll posts to QuickBooks books without export
- Tax filing included
- Same day pay options
- Higher total cost with accounting
- Per worker fee near $7
How we picked these
We compared official pricing pages and public buyer guides for payroll tools with published low prices and full service tax filing, where offered. We favoured tools live in October 2026, with clear base plus per person pricing, and we noted where a plan does not file taxes or covers only some states. Prices change with promotions, so confirm the live page before you buy.
What to check before you buy
Price payroll for your real headcount, not for one employee. A $4 per person rate versus a $12 rate looks small for five staff and large for twenty, and multi state fees, benefits and time tracking add ons change the ranking. Ask each vendor for a total monthly figure for your staff count, states and pay frequency.
Confirm tax filing for your states
Full service should mean the vendor calculates, files and deposits federal, state and local taxes for your locations. Confirm coverage for every state you pay staff in, including local taxes, and ask what happens if a filing is late. A cheap plan that leaves filing to you is not cheap once quarterly returns arrive.
Test a real pay run
Run a trial pay run with your actual mix of hourly, salaried, contractor and overtime staff, if you have them. Check direct deposit timing, pay stub clarity, year end W-2 and 1099 handling, and how corrections are made. A tool that handles a simple salary run well may struggle with your real mix.
FAQ
What is the cheapest payroll software for a small business?
Patriot has the lowest listed monthly price among full service tools in recent comparisons, at $37 plus $5 per worker for Full Service, while Basic at $17 plus $4 does not file taxes. Square Payroll is close, at $35 plus $6 per employee, and SurePayroll starts near $29.99 plus $5.
What is the best cheap payroll service overall?
Gusto is a common overall pick, despite costing more than Patriot or Square, because it combines full tax filing, onboarding and benefits in a clear interface. The best cheap payroll service for you depends on headcount, states and whether you need HR features.
Do these tools file payroll taxes for me?
Full service plans at Gusto, OnPay, Square, QuickBooks and Patriot Full Service file federal, state and local taxes, subject to state coverage. Patriot Basic and Wave outside its tax service states calculate amounts but leave filing to you, so check plan details.
Can I pay contractors and employees in the same system?
Yes, on every platform here, though pricing differs. Square offers a contractor only plan with no base fee, while most others charge contractors at the standard per person rate in months you pay them. Check terms for 1099 handling.
Is there a free payroll option?
None of the full service tools on this list offers a free payroll plan, though several offer trials or promotions. Free tools exist for basic calculation, but they leave tax filing and compliance to you, which is a poor trade for most employers.




